Tuesday, August 9, 2016

Pokemon and Fundamentalist Christianity

What Pokémon Go Can Teach about Fundamentalism

With the smash hit release of Pokémon Go, a small number of fundamentalist Christian critics have complained about its demonic nature. These reactions against Pokémon can tell us about the nature of fundamentalism.

The most prominent of these current critics is Rick Wiles from Trunews, a fundamentalist Christian radio program and blog. On this program he complains that virtual demons are being placed in churches. He believes the game is a magnet for demonic powers and that Pokémon masters may tell the demons to kill Christians. 

As far-fetched as this may seem, he is not the only current critic that believes in the potential demonic power of Pokemon.
Another current critic, Erika Dawson, wrote a blog post titled “Is Pokémon Safe for Christian Kids.” In this post she quotes Rebecca Woodson’s Let Our Children Go: Steps to Free Your Child from Evil Influences published by the fundamentalist publisher Charisma House:
We must not assume that our children are not a threat to darkness. The enemy’s purpose is to grip and blind every generation, establishing strongholds in the lives of our children from a very young age. – Rebecca Greenwood

Continuing she offers the following introductory questions to determine whether should let your child play 
Pokémon and other games:·

· What does this game teach you?
· Are supernatural powers involved?
· Does the show, character, story, etc. go against or line up with God’s Word?
· Does the game or toy have symbols, characters, or other characteristics that link it to New Age or occult powers?
· What influence does the game exert?


Both of these commentaries appeared after Pokémon Go was released, but fundamentalists have been critiquing Pokémon since its initial popularity. In 2001, Phil Arms published a book called Pokémon and Harry Potter a Fatal Attraction, where he also complains about the demonic nature of Pokémon. The above referenced book complains about the magical power of Pokémon and lists it alongside World of Warcraft and Dungeons and Dragons as games to be avoided. 

Jigglypuff, an example used by Phil Arms in a sermon about the demonic nature of Pokemon

Berit Kjos in his article “Pokemon: A Christian Commentary,” argues that Pokemon is a gateway into other spiritually dangerous games such as Magic the Gathering and Dungeons and Dragons. And these games are ways to teach children formulas for summoning spirits and gives children a sense of personal power:
Children everywhere are learning the pagan formulas for invoking “angelic” or demonic spirits through multicultural education, popular books, movies, and television. It’s not surprising that deadly explosions of untamed violence suddenly erupt from “normal” teens across our land. Occult role-playing games teach the same dangerous lessons. They also add a sense of personal power and authority through personal identification with godlike superheroes. Though the demonic realm hasn’t changed, today’s technology, media, and multicultural climate makes it easier to access, and harder than ever to resist its appeal. 
In this conception of reality, true power can only come from God and any other apparent power is from the enemy. These examples all emphasize that the spiritual world, populated with literal angels and demons, is an essential part of reality. So much so that even the more mainstream fundamentalist Christian organization Focus on the Family references potential demonic influences: “some of the claims of demonic influences in Pokémon seem overblown.”

This emphasis of the physical world being intertwined with and affected by the spiritual world can give us insight into fundamentalism. George Marsden is one of the most respected historians of evangelicalism and fundamentalism and he defines fundamentalism as:

…an evangelical who is militant in opposition to liberal theology in the churches or to changes in cultural values or mores, such as those associated with ‘secular humanism.’ --George M. Marsden, Understanding Fundamentalism and Evangelicalism (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans,1991), vii.

In my proposed conception of fundamentalism the opposition to changes and liberal theology/culture will center on instances where their conception of reality is opposed or denied. Their conception of reality is one that combines the moral, metaphysical spirituality, and physical reality in a whole that cannot be separated. 


Pokémon arguably have supernatural powers and representations of supernatural powers allow real spiritual beings to interact with the physical world, but any fictionalization of spiritual reality will be opposed. From their perspective, Harry Potter, Dungeons and Dragons, Magic the Gathering, and others are mistakenly treated as fictional by most of contemporary society; whereas, for the fundamentalist these books, movies, and games both call into being real unwanted spiritual realities and are an actual representation of an unwanted spiritual reality. And thus a beacon for demonic activity. 

According to fundamentalism, this tendency of contemporary society to fictionalize the spiritual is based on a profound misunderstanding of the metaphysical nature of reality. It is as good as saying the spiritual world does not exist; in other words, there is a large component of reality that most of us are simply unware of. Thus, from the fundamentalist’s perspective, we are unaware of the spiritual warfare happening all around us.

This tripartite conception of reality predates modernity. Natural historians and natural philosophers of the 1800s, such as Newton, saw the empirical ‘scientific’ world and the spiritual as deeply connected, much like contemporary fundamentalists. Morality was not viewed as quite as essential to reality, but it was still common to suggest that people under demonic influence committed immoral acts.

Contemporary conceptions of reality separate or deny these aspects of reality. Morality is separated from spirituality when atheists say you can be good without God. Morality is separated from reality when people deny objective moral truths by espousing various form of moral relativism. Spiritual reality is outright denied by scientists who espouse metaphysical naturalism, that everything is potentially explainable through natural explanations. And since fundamentalists are at war, the rest of us are, at best, innocent bystanders in the most epic war in all of history.


Monday, June 13, 2016

Thoughts for/on Orlando: Current Events


Politico tweeted that Trump had failed to meet the moment after Orlando and thinking about it so did I. This post is an apology for not addressing the tragedy in Orlando sooner. There is no simple response. It is a tragedy.

While reading about the tragedy, I found myself wanting to be there with those mourning. And I think that is a good and proper response when something like this happens. Not necessarily trying to do anything, but just being there.

50 people died and 53 people were injured in a place that many of them considered to be a sanctuary or their safe place. Away from people who will judge them from holding their beloved's hand, away from people who jeer at them for giving their partner a quick kiss, and, except for this day, away from people who threaten violence. I want these people to feel safe in this world and this terrorist took one of the few safe places away from them.

But this response is inadequate. This response does at least take into consideration their particular community; however, it still fails to take in all of the political aspects of this tragedy. Perhaps you think this should not be politicized, but these people's lives have been politicized.

Grace's comment is in response to the observation that many members of the GOP failed to mention the location or that the people dead and injured were LGBTQ or allies. This trend is not limited to senators and members of congress though. 

The popular apologist Lee Strobel saw no difference between this mass shooting and the mass shooting in Aurora that took place in a movie theatre:


My call to readers, friends, and colleagues who read this post is simply to allow all of the issues from this event to wash over you and to think about our place in the world. This event has several political aspects. Islamic terrorism, mental health, gun control, and homophobia. Simply saying this is a tragedy, even if you talk about the fact that the target was a Florida LGBTQ community is not adequate. 

We need to be there for these people and we need to discuss the conditions led to the largest single person mass shooting in American history.















Wednesday, May 25, 2016

Current Events: Bathroom Laws (Warning slightly adult content)


Of all the current events I imagined myself covering on this blog I would have never guessed restrooms would be one of them. Many are talking about trans people and which restrooms they should enter. What I thought was a simple inquiry into @NYapologetics position on twitter turned into (I assume) mutually disappointing conversation. I am using that conversation as a jumping off point for this post.

First, I should explain why I am even covering this, because it is not obviously about religion.

The first answer is that the impetus for this post was a twitter interaction with the aforementioned @NYapologetics. Their website is www.newyorkapologetics.com 

The second is that a strict binary of restrooms is disproportionately supported by evangelicals; thus, this issue is divided along religious lines. The reason: many evangelicals believe that God distinctly created us to be male or female and have different moral obligations, while many mainline Christians and non-church goes do not believe that gender is NOT strictly binary. 

Look at what Ken Ham the president of the Answers in Genesis, a creationist organization has to say about Target's restroom policy.

Also, there have been evangelicals protesting Target's policy.

Now compare these positions to one promoted by Rachel Held Evans an ex-evangelical. 

Twitter exchange with @NYapologetics


In my very long twitter exchange with @NYapologetics, they thought I never answered their main question and I never felt that I was never given a concrete policy. I originally engaged in this conversation because I was genuinely curious about alternatives to allowing people to use the restroom of the gender that they identify with.

Their main question boiled down to: how do we protect the rights of 99.7% who would suffer potential abuse/feel uncomfortable due to policies that allow people to go to the restroom of the gender they identify with. I maintained (and still maintain) that forcing the choice of restroom on a person in transition would actually decrease safety and increase discomfort.

One of the first things I did was survey some people I knew. Granted this is not a representative nor a very large sample, but I do want to share two anonymous sentiments that I received from women:
If they were going to build another restroom, I would prefer they just spend the money on making women's restrooms larger. 
These people [like @NYapologetics] are making me uncomfortable by sexualizing restrooms.
I received no sentiments that they were worried about increased abuse. Though, I want to emphasize that I did not even attempt to do a comprehensive survey. However, someone else did do a survey. It found that women and young people are more comfortable with trans people in the restroom of their choice than older men.

I think it would enlightening for someone to conduct different survey. The survey would ask: how comfortable would you be if someone who is obviously dressed and presents themselves as a woman enters the men's restroom and vice versa.

Here are a couple of examples:



Would you be comfortable with this person in the men's restroom?



Or this person in the woman's restroom?

Bold and the Beautiful: Transgender Actor Scott Turner Schofield Cast

In case it is not obvious, the person in the top image is a transwoman (born with a penis, for those not in the loop) and the bottom image is of a transman. 

I suspect that these individuals using the restroom of the their birth-sex would make just about everyone uncomfortable.

But what about abuse?


In every locale that has regulations allowing trans people to go to the restroom of their choice there has been no statistical increase in abuse. 

There really isn't much more to say. Trans people in restrooms makes (mostly) older men uncomfortable and they claim to be defending women and children from predators, when there just isn't any evidence that Target-like non-discriminatory policies increase sexual abuse. 

And to be clear I would be very concerned if there was any evidence that it did increase sexual abuse. To reiterate, I would be very very concerned.

Other proposals:


NYapologetics maintained a third restroom would be an acceptable solution. However, they also produced one other option, simply making the rule standard that you must use the restroom of your birth sex. 


Policy 1: A Third Restroom


A third restroom is not a practical solution for two reasons. 

First, outside of large areas like stadiums and airports there is just not space. And these places typically already have family restrooms that would likely suffice. But this is not just possible in a standard restaurant, bar, or shopping center.

Second, you are putting people who identify as different genders into the same restroom. Trans people are NOT all the same in their gender identity, most trans people would not appreciate this. You might be able to avoid this to some degree if you make it a locked room, but again, in places that are large enough already have family restrooms. Thus to make this feasible at all, you would likely need four restrooms: one for those born male, one for those born female, one for those transitioning into male, and one for those transitioning into female. 

Policy 2: Back to the Golden Age


Their second suggestion was to only allow those born male use the men's restroom and those born women use the women's restroom. They maintained that this was the original policy; and, things got mucked up when we started trying to make more complicated rules about restrooms. I was not able to get an answer as to how they would enforce this policy. 

Even so, I emphatically disagree that this was the original policy. The original (unstated) policy was that if you looked like a man you walked into the men's restroom and if you looked female you walked into the women's restroom. No one really checked. There was little if any dichotomy between birth sex and gender expression. 

If birth sex is/was the policy as opposed to appearance we would have developed a way to check the birth sex. The fact is that people who don't look enough like their gender (usually women who are dressed masculine) sometimes get harassed going into the restroom of their birth sex. (Note: I am only using this link as evidence that someone was harassed, it was not actually in relation to HB2).

Bottom line: 


These policies proposed by @NYapologetics don't work and the initial question assumes that non-discriminatory policies make people are uncomfortable (which admittedly SOME are, but mostly older men) and that these policies also lead to abuse (which they don't). 

I am open ears to new policies would help more people be more comfortable, in fact this is my main question on this issue. Please comment with any concrete proposal.