Showing posts with label Creationism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Creationism. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 5, 2016

Open Letter to Ken Ham

Dear Ken Ham, 



Let me begin by stating I am sincerely attempting to understand. 

The subject of this open letter is a request that you clarify your definition/conception of religion. You often state that critics of your creation museum are following their secular, evolutionary, and/or atheistic religion.  

There are virtually no definitions of religion that would result in secularism, evolution, or atheism being considered religious. 

That being said, I think your definition of religion would be "a belief system that is unchanging and fundamental to your overall worldview."

If this is correct, I am unsure how you would differentiate between a religious belief system/worldview and a non-religious belief system/worldview. Or under your conception, is it even possible to be non-religious?

And is going to church, temple, sangha (etc...), participation in rituals, and communal experience purely tangential to being religious?

As of yet I have not been able to find an explicit definition of your concept of religion. Though, you seem to be very comfortable claiming that secularism, evolution, and atheism are religions. 

In full disclosure, I have given a great deal of thought into the definition of religion and I prefer definitions that emphasize the community aspects of religion (i.e. religion is a community that shares beliefs and rituals). 

This is the conception of religion that I would defend; though, I am open to using other conceptions as needed. 

Other conceptions include: individual belief and experience, collective group experience (which aligns very nicely with community), morality, and more. 

Thus, I accept J.Z. Smith's analysis that religion is the construction of the thinker. 

In other words, you need to provide the rationale by which you are 'imagining religion'.

The request of this open letter is for you to be as transparent as I have been in this letter about how you 'imagine religion.' 

We cannot even have a debate about whether evolution, secularism, and atheism are religious, because you have not yet explicitly defined or conceptualized 'religion'.

Definitions are important. And before I can even think about changing my mind on evolution and etc... being religious, I would need to see it defined. I have provided my thoughts about religion, it is now your turn. 

Alternatively you could simply stop calling evolution, secularism, and atheism religions.




In the hopes of understanding, 

A Religion Critic




*Addition 5/5/2016

Continuining my search for a definition of religion, I have found one endorsed by AiG's Tim Chaffey: "A cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith." This is the fourth definition from Merriam-Webster. He seems to arbitrarily choose this definition over the first and neglects all scholarly definitions of religion.

Ardor and faith are not sufficient to call something a religion, unless a hardcore Red Sox fan is religious. These fans have an unwavering belief that theirs is the best team and they have an ardor that is above many who I would call religious. 


Thus, Chaffey's definition includes things that I would be very hesitant to call religious. Granted there is no clear line separating religion and non-religion, but I will reject any definition that includes baseball. (Perhaps I am biased against baseball).

I also found more information about Ken Ham's conception of religion. His conception seems to include a comprehensive worldview, origins of the universe, origins of humanity, and moral codes. This is based on a Facebook post from November 4, 2015 and sections of the book Inside the Nye Ham Debate. 

Ham's conception has the benefit of potentially distinguishing religion vs. non-religion through comprehensiveness and origins. Though Ruism (what many call Confucianism) doesn't really have any position about the origin of the universe or humanity. And these are (mostly) lacking in Buddhism as well. 

Perhaps a comprehensive metaphysical belief system is sufficient for Ham's conception. This would allow him to include both Ruism and Buddhism.

Though, it would be strange for Ham, the president of AiG (Answers in Genesis), which focuses on origins, to admit that origins do not matter when categorizing something as religious. Not impossible, but strange. 

With what I think is a better understanding, I now challenge Ham to debate over how word religion is used. He is using a particular conception of the word because it serves his purposes. And he has not yet, to my knowledge, justified this 'imagination' of religion. 



Sunday, June 28, 2015

Current events post I: Review of Laudato Si


      
Unification of Morality, Theology, and Science in Laudato Si

          Papal encyclicals, like Laudato Si, are part of the social teaching of the Catholic Church. They are possibly the single most authoritative statement a Pope can make by himself, that is when he is not speaking ex cathedra (for the Church).
         
          Laudato Si is the first Papal encyclical to focus primarily on climate change. It deserves attention for what it is and isn’t, and for its sheer beauty. It is a reasoned position of how we should come together to care for the earth. However, it isn’t a document that limits its commentary to environmental concerns. As with my book reviews, I would like to give a short summary and offer a critical review.

140 word Summary:
         
          We are in need of a new dialogue centered on protecting Earth, our common home. Becoming painfully aware of the changing world and discovering possibilities for action are the challenges facing humanity. If present trends continue this century may witness extraordinary climate change. Deterioration of the natural environment, for example greater scarcity of water, disproportionately affects the poor. Unless our full uniqueness is acknowledged, humans cannot be expected to feel responsibility. Care for the world must be flexible and dynamic and must include justice for the less fortunate and future generations. Deterioration of the environment diminishes human quality of life. Self-centeredness, encouraged by markets, promotes extreme consumerism, increasing this deterioration. We need to drastically change the current techno-economic paradigm if we are to care for each other and the environment. We need to promote and unify all the great values.

Extended Critique and Analysis:
         
          The phrase ‘Laudato Si’ is taken from St. Francis of Assisi’s Canticle of the Sun, a poem where God is praised for various aspects of his creation. While Laudato Si’s most central theme is care for the earth, he often veers into social teachings on concern for the poor, abortion, and gender theory. From a secular point of view this might be confusing. But if we can understand this ‘veering’ as part of a unified cosmology/metaphysic it can at least make sense to those of us who are not Catholic.

          First, there is a beauty in the document that should be appreciated and savored:

“This sister (Mother Earth) now cries out to us because of the harm we have inflicted on her by our irresponsible use and abuse of the goods with which God has endowed her. We have come to see ourselves as her lords and masters, entitled to plunder her at will. The violence present in our hearts, wounded by sin, is also reflected in the symptoms of sickness evident in the soil, in the water, in the air and in all forms of life.” (Laudato Si, Intro, Paragraph 2)
          Pope Francis’ argument is almost poetry. It is a lamentation of human caused damage, yet it is still optimistic that we can come together as a common family to find a solution to care for all Creation. This care must extend to humanity, including the poor.
          Concern for the poor is given at least equal time in Laudato Si as climate change. By my count, ‘poor’ (not including the superlatives ‘poorer’ and ‘poorest’) and ‘inequality’ were used 53 times; while the words ‘climate’ and ‘ecology’ were used 48 times. Pope Francis argues that we can’t extend care to all of Creation and not extend it to the less fortunate and defenseless of our own species, including the unborn:

“Since everything is interrelated, concern for the protection of nature is also incompatible with the justification of abortion. How can we genuinely teach the importance of concern for other vulnerable beings, however troublesome or inconvenient they may be, if we fail to protect a human embryo, even when its presence is uncomfortable and creates difficulties?” (Laudato Si, Ch. 3, Paragraph 120)

This concern extends to the integrity of our bodies, including adherence to our biological sex:

“Also, valuing one’s own body in its femininity or masculinity is necessary if I am going to be able to recognize myself in an encounter with someone who is different. In this way we can joyfully accept the specific gifts of another man or woman, the work of God the Creator, and find mutual enrichment. It is not a healthy attitude which would seek “to cancel out sexual difference because it no longer knows how to confront it.” (Laudato Si, Ch. 4, Paragraph 155).
          Thus, Pope Francis is concerned with human ecology in a very particularly Catholic way, unifying the great values of theology, morality, and science. 

Bottom Line:
         
          Pope Francis is not the only religious figure to demonstrate a propensity to unify theology, morality, and science. On February 4, 2014 Bill Nye, the science guy, and Ken Ham, spokesperson for the Creation Museum, debated the topic “Is Creation a Viable Model of Origins.” As I argue elsewhere Ham views morality, theology, and science as deeply interconnected. He also references gender identity in a debate about science. However, his ecological system is different.

          Ham’s ecological view is one in which God created a more or less fixed Creation and climate variations are the result of the earth settling down after Noah’s flood. Thus, climate change is a return to normalcy and stasis inherent in the original Creation. The Pope, unlike Ham, accepts the physical evolution of everything, including humanity, only rejecting the idea that the human mind/soul evolved. The difference then is one system is static or at least tending towards stasis; the other is capable of change partially based on our collective actions. The similarity between the two is their profound unity.
         
          There is a unified cosmology/metaphysic in both. These cosmologies inform morality, politics, economic theory, and (though to lesser extent for the Pope) science. This is what a strong cosmology/metaphysical system does. It allows disparate human activities to be connected into a single framework. If we do not understand that others have different cosmologies/metaphysics, we will not be able to truly understand each other.